This article was originally published on TVBee
Marcus Grodd & Lacy Faddoul, Season 1 - Never Legally Married
Bachelor in Paradise's Marcus Grodd and Lacy Faddoul seemed to have found love in paradise. The first season ended with Marcus proposing to Lacy, and fans were ecstatic to see the couple take their relationship to the next level. But as it turned out, their marriage wasn't legal, and things quickly fell apart. Apparently the paperwork to officiate their marriage was never completed because Lacy stalled and avoided it. Clearly, she wasn't actually all in.
According to Marcus, Lacy changed after they left Mexico, and the relationship became toxic. They couldn't overcome this, and their relationship failed.
Trista Rehn & Ryan Sutter, Season 1 - Going Strong
Trista Rehn and Ryan Sutter's fairy tale romance on the first season of The Bachelorette gave birth to the franchise's massive popularity. The lovebirds' televised wedding ceremony in 2003 drew millions of viewers worldwide. But the picture-perfect couple has not been spared from the challenges of a real relationship. They are going on two decades together, which is a milestone for any couple, let alone a couple that met on reality TV!
Trista Rehn and Ryan Sutter are a true testament to the success of The Bachelor franchise. As the first couple to get together and stay together, they've set the bar high for all those who followed in their footsteps.
JoJo Fletcher & Jordan Rodgers, Season 12 - Starting a Family
The Bachelorette season 12 might have aired a while ago, but JoJo Fletcher and Jordan Rodgers' love story is still going strong. From the moment they met, sparks flew, and it was clear that they were meant to be. After a beautiful proposal on the finale, the couple was set to get married in the summer of 2020, but the pandemic had other plans. However, they didn't let that dampen their spirits, and in 2022, they finally tied the knot in a beautiful ceremony.
Now that they're officially husband and wife, and can't help but have baby fever. According to the lovebirds themselves, they're definitely ready to start a family soon.
Becca Kufrin & Thomas Jacobs, Season 7 - In Love
Former Bachelorette, Becca Kufrin, is back and better than ever! The stunning reality TV star made her third franchise appearance on Bachelor in Paradise, where she hit things off with the tall and handsome Thomas Jacobs. The couple had a rollercoaster of a relationship with plenty of ups and downs. But, despite splitting up on the show, the duo managed to find their way back to each other, and they’re still going strong!
Becca even took to Instagram to apologize to Jacob for the public breakup, and the couple is now happier than ever. It just goes to show that sometimes, the third time really is the charm!
Michelle Young & Nayte Olukoya, Season 18 - Broken up
Bachelor Nation fans were rooting for Michelle Young to find her happily ever after. It seemed like she had finally met her perfect match with Nayte Olukoya on The Bachelorette. After a whirlwind romance and a beautiful proposal, Young was over the moon. But months later, the couple called off their engagement, leaving fans wondering what went wrong. Rumors of infidelity were swirling, but Olukoya took to Instagram to deny the allegations.
In his first interview since the split, he revealed that he missed the woman he fell in love with but wasn't sure if he missed the Michelle he broke up with.
Clare Crawley & Dale Moss, Season 16 - Separated
Grab your popcorn because the Clare Crawley and Dale Moss saga is one for the books! The couple's love story has been a rollercoaster ride - first, they got engaged on Season 16 of The Bachelorette, but then they called it quits. However, they couldn't stay apart for long, and soon they were back together, sporting engagement rings and even celebrating a one-year anniversary in July 2021. People were thrilled to see the lovebirds back on track.
But alas, it was short-lived, as they broke up again in September 2021. The ups and downs of their relationship have kept us all on the edge of our seats, and who knows, maybe they'll find their way back to each other once again.
Peter Weber & Madison Prewett, Season 24 - Split up
Hold onto your roses, Bachelor Nation, because we're about to spill some tea on Peter Weber and Madison Prewett's ill-fated romance! The season 24 finale of The Bachelor saw Peter stuck between two girls, Hannah Ann Sluss and Madison. Even though Madison skipped the final rose ceremony, he chose her. However, he must've chosen wrong because they didn't get along and had major disagreements over morals and faith, which led to their devastating breakup.
Peter has moved on to other relationships, but his breakup with Madison still haunts him. He even shared, "It was literally the most trying and most difficult experience I have ever been through."
Ali Fedotowsky & Roberto Martinez, Season 6 - Engagement Called off
It was the fairytale ending that everyone was rooting for, but sadly, it wasn't meant to be. Ali Fedotowsky and Roberto Martinez's love story came to an end just 18 months after their romantic proposal on The Bachelorette Season 6. Despite their chemistry on the show, Ali and Roberto struggled to make it work in the real world. Apparently, their personalities clashed, and Ali didn't like that Roberto was such an introvert.
Fast forward to today, and Ali has found happiness with TV host Kevin Manno, while Roberto announced his engagement to Kristiana Elliott in December 2019. Will they find the happy ending they both deserve? Only time will tell.
Caelynn Miller-Keyes & Dean Unglert, Season 6 - Engaged
It's a love story that has defied all the odds! Caelynn Miller-Keyes and Dean Unglert's journey from Bachelor in Paradise to their brand-new Las Vegas home has been one wild ride. Fans of the couple were on the edge of their seats during the show as they battled through some tough times. But since leaving the show, they have proved that their love is stronger than ever and got engaged last year!
With two adopted senior dogs, a wedding on the way, and now a brand-new home, it seems like nothing can stand in the way of this couple's happiness.
Hannah Godwin & Dylan Barbour, Season 6 - Still Together
Hannah Godwin, the gorgeous blonde bombshell, had not one but two hunks vying for her affection on the show. And while Blake Horstmann certainly had his charms, she ultimately chose to put a ring on it with the swoon-worthy Dylan Barbour. But the real drama unfolded after the cameras stopped rolling. Who knew a pandemic lockdown could lead to true love? This couple went from long-distance to unexpectedly living together.
They even took the plunge by buying a house in sunny San Diego! It looks like things are heating up for Hannah and Dylan; we wonder what could be next.
Sean Lowe & Catherine Giudici, Season 17 - Married With Kids
The Bachelor franchise was elated to see Sean Lowe and Catherine Giudici's love story unfold on screen. Lowe was known as the "born-again virgin," and Giudici was the quirky graphic designer who stole his heart. After Lowe proposed to Giudici in the finale of Season 17, their wedding was highly anticipated by Bachelor Nation. The couple even got their own televised wedding special, and viewers were able to witness their romantic ceremony.
Since then, the happy couple has built a beautiful life together and had kids; what a success story!
Ben Higgins & Lauren Bushnell, Season 20 - Separated
Bachelor Nation was captivated by Ben Higgins' emotional journey to find love on Season 20 of The Bachelor. After expressing his love to both JoJo Fletcher and Lauren Bushnell, he made the difficult decision to choose Bushnell. The two seemed to be a match made in heaven, starring in their own reality show and sharing their love story with the world. But soon enough, their love all came crashing down.
While Lauren found love again with country singer Chris Lane and started a family, Ben found a new flame and got married. It seems that even Bachelor breakups can lead to happy endings.
Deanna Pappas & Jesse Csincsak, Season 4 - Split
Deanna Pappas may have found love on The Bachelorette, but it wasn't meant to last forever. After getting engaged to Jesse Csincsak, the couple's relationship fizzled out before they could walk down the aisle. However, both found love again within Bachelor Nation. Deanna married Stephen Stagliano, but they decided to part ways after 11 years of marriage. Jesse Csincsak, on the other hand, has also found happiness outside of his relationship with DeAnna.
After their split, he went on to marry Ann Lueders, who was a contestant on Jason Mesnick's season of The Bachelor. The couple tied the knot in 2010 and have since welcomed three children.
Arie Luyendyk Jr. & Lauren Burnham, Season 22 - Married
It seems like Arie Luyendyk Jr. can't make up his mind when it comes to love! After proposing to Becca Kurfin in Season 22 of The Bachelor, he quickly changed his tune and ended up breaking her heart in a televised breakup that had fans up in arms. But that wasn't the end of the drama. In a shocking twist, he then proposed to runner-up Lauren Burnham, who accepted, leaving viewers stunned.
Their relationship has been rocky, with rumors of infidelity swirling around Arie. However, the couple has managed to weather the storm and are now proud parents to three kids.
Carly Waddell & Evan Bass, Season 3 - Divorced
Bachelor in Paradise's Evan Bass and Carly Waddell were one of the show's most beloved couples, but sadly, their love story has ended. After tying the knot in a beautiful ceremony in Mexico in 2017 and welcoming two adorable children, the reality stars' announced their split only three years later. It surprised many, but they both agreed that the foundation of their marriage wasn't strong enough to withstand the challenges of real life.
Despite trying therapy and giving it their all, they decided to go their separate ways. But there's plenty more where that came from, so get ready to fall in love (or out of it) with these captivating Bachelor Nation love stories.
Demi Burnett & Kristian Haggerty, Season 6 - Broken up
Demi Burnett was already making headlines on Bachelor in Paradise as a feisty and controversial contestant, but she really shook things up when she came out publicly as bisexual during season 6. Her ex-girlfriend Kristian Haggerty showed up in Mexico to try to reconcile, and the pair briefly rekindled their romance on the show. They even got engaged, marking the first time in Bachelor Nation history that a same-sex couple had taken that step.
But their happy ending was short-lived, as they ultimately admitted that they had fallen out of love. Despite the breakup, Demi and Kristian have remained supportive of each other and are proud of their love story's impact on the franchise.
Kevin Wendt & Astrid Loch, Season 5 - Married With a Baby
Love truly found a way for Kevin Wendt and Astrid Loch from Bachelor in Paradise Season 5. The couple went through a rough patch on the show and eventually broke up, leaving Bachelor Nation to wonder if they were ever going to rekindle their romance. But fate had other plans. Kevin and Astrid reignited their love off-screen and got engaged in a romantic proposal in his hometown of Toronto in 2019!
And if that wasn't exciting enough, the couple had their first child together, and their love story just keeps getting better.
Hannah Brown & Jed Wyatt, Season 15 - Broken up
Grab a tissue because the drama keeps on coming! Hannah Brown's search for love on The Bachelorette was a rocky road filled with heartbreak and betrayal. After choosing Jed Wyatt, their love lasted about two days, and Hannah was heartbroken. It was revealed on the show's finale that Jed had been seeing someone else before he came on the show, which is incredibly shady. Why go on a show to find love if you're taken?
She may not have found true love on-screen, but off-screen, she's had better luck. She left the drama of reality TV behind and found her happily ever after with her boyfriend, Adam Woolard.
Tayshia Adams & Zac Clark, Season 16 - Broken up
We were left heartbroken when Tayshia Adams and Zac Clark called it quits after over a year of being engaged. The couple, who fell in love and got engaged during Season 16 of The Bachelorette, seemed to be the epitome of true love. But apparently, love wasn't enough for these two to make it work. They just couldn't align their schedules and make time for each other, inevitably leading to a breakup.
Despite Tayshia's heartbreak, she's been living her best life in the Big Apple, enjoying the single life and all that New York City has to offer. As for Zac, he's been keeping things low-key.
Chris Bukowski & Katie Morton, Season 6 - Broken up
Chris Bukowski and Katie Morton, who got engaged on Bachelor in Paradise, have called it quits. While they seemed over the moon in Mexico, their relationship quickly soured once they returned home. Katie stopped wearing her engagement ring, and fans noticed, wondering what went wrong. The couple tried to work through their issues, but sadly, it wasn't meant to be. They announced their breakup in December 2019, leaving fans devastated.
Katie took to social media to share her thoughts, reminding us that it's okay to be stubborn in the pursuit of happiness.
Jade Roper & Tanner Tolbert, Season 2 - Married With Kids
Season 2 of Bachelor in Paradise was filled with drama and controversy, but one couple managed to survive it all. Jade Roper and Tanner Tolbert's engagement had Bachelor Nation rooting for them, but their relationship was soon rocked by scandal. In 2020, rumors surfaced that Tanner cheated on Jade while pregnant with their third child. The couple denied the allegations, but the damage was already done, and the public isn't so sure.
Despite the drama, their marriage has continued to endure, and they remain one of the few successful couples to come out of the Bachelor franchise.
Chris Randone & Krystal Nielson, Season 5 - Divorced
Bachelor Nation fans were shocked when Chris Randone and Krystal Nielson announced their split on Valentine's Day 2020, just months after their televised wedding officiated by Chris Harrison. Their whirlwind romance started on Season 5 of Bachelor in Paradise, where they fell hard and fast for each other, despite their villainous reputations from their previous Bachelor/Bachelorette appearances. But what went wrong? Chris admitted that there were warning signs and mixed signals during their relationship.
Their conflicting schedules put a strain on their marriage, and they ultimately agreed to get a divorce. Hopefully, other couples have better luck!
Katie Thurston & Blake Moynes, Season 17 - Split up
The Bachelorette has seen plenty of failed relationships, and season 17 was no different for the shortlived romance between Katie Thurston and Blake Moynes. Their love fizzled quickly, and the couple announced their split in October 2021, citing distance as the main factor, but Katie hasn't shied away from poking fun at her failed engagement. During a stand-up comedy set, she joked about her engagement being fake, something many past contestants have also shared.
How can The Bachelorette be fake? It's not like anyone would ever pretend to fall in love for the sake of being on TV.
Tayshia Adams & John Paul Jones, Season 6 - Separated
Tayshia Adams and John Paul Jones were a couple no one expected. After a tumultuous end to their time on Bachelor in Paradise, Tayshia had a change of heart. She decided to fly to John's house to beg for another chance. But would it work out this time around? We were rooting for the couple, but unfortunately, their reunion was short-lived. Despite their best efforts, Tayshia & John just couldn't make their relationship work.
We will always wonder what could have been if they had managed to work things out! Keep reading to find out all about the latest couples and their rollercoaster relationships.
Joe Amabile & Kendall Long, Season 5 - Split up
We were rooting for Joe Amabile and Kendall Long since they first appeared on Bachelor in Paradise Season 5. However, their relationship was a rollercoaster. After a brief break-up following the show, the two reunited and even moved in together. But their love story hit a rough patch in January 2020 when they called it quits for good after dating for nearly two years. But what happened next was even more shocking.
They appeared on the 2021 season of The Bachelor spinoff, and things got awkward when Joe fell in love with someone else, and Kendall had to watch.
Juan Pablo Galavis & Nikki Ferrell, Season 18 - Divorced
Juan Pablo Galavis was one of the most controversial Bachelors of all time, known for his rude behavior and lack of commitment to the women on the show. It was shocking for all when Nikki Ferrell decided to stay with him despite his not proposing, and even more so when they later appeared on Couples Therapy. They got married but divorced within two years. With both of them now happily married to other people, things seemed to work out for the best.
But we can't help but wonder, what really went on behind the scenes during their tumultuous time on the show? You might wonder the same when you read about some of these other couples too!
Clayton Echard & Susie Evans, Season 26 - Separated
Season 26 of The Bachelor had more twists and turns than a rollercoaster! Clayton Echard had viewers on the edge of their seats when he revealed his intimate relationships with Rachel Recchi and Gabby Windey. But despite the shocking confession, he ultimately chose Susie Evans as his final rose recipient. However, their relationship was far from smooth sailing, and after Susie initially walked away from Clayton, the couple eventually reunited and tried to rebuild their love.
But just when it seemed like they were in it for the long haul, they announced their split just one month after moving out of their shared home.
Becca Kufrin & Garrett Yrigoyen, Season 14 - Separated
Former Bachelorette Becca Kufrin and Garrett Yrigoyen's relationship had the odds stacked against them since the beginning. After Garrett was exposed for liking a series of insensitive posts on Instagram that were transphobic, homophobic and promoted conspiracy theories about school shootings, Becca reevaluated their lives together. They decided to split in 2020, and it was for the best. Becca was scared if they had children together, it would be difficult because their values were so different.
These Bachelor Nation couples have certainly been through the wringer with their dramatic love lives. You'll have to keep reading to find out more about the other wild stars.
Emily Maynard & Jef Holm, Season 8 - Separated
Emily Maynard's search for love on The Bachelorette may have ended in disappointment with her breakup with Jef Holm, but she eventually found her happily ever after with Tyler Johnson. However, her past with Holm still lingers in the tabloids. In 2012, rumors of cheating and money-spinning allegations surfaced, which ultimately led to the couple's split. Despite the drama, Maynard moved on with Johnson and tied the knot in 2014.
Together they have five children, including Maynard's teenage daughter from a previous relationship. Although her relationship with Holm didn't work out, Maynard's love story with Johnson proves that true love can come after heartbreak.
Raven Gates & Adam Gottschalk, Season 4 - Married
Raven Gates and Adam Gottschalk have officially started their own little family. The couple, who met on season four of Bachelor in Paradise, recently welcomed their first child together, a son. Their love story may not have started with a proposal on the show, but they proved that real love can be found off-camera. After years of dating, they finally got engaged but delayed their wedding several times due to the pandemic.
But the wait was worth it, as they finally exchanged their vows in a beautiful ceremony in 2021 and welcomed their baby a year later.
Rachel Lindsay & Bryan Abasolo, Season 13 - In Love
Rachel Lindsay's journey on The Bachelorette was filled with ups and downs, but in the end, she found the love of her life. She broke barriers as the franchise's first African-American lead, and her relationship with Bryan Abasolo proved to be one of the most successful in the show's history. After getting engaged on the season 13 finale, the couple relocated to Miami and tied the knot in a romantic ceremony in Mexico.
They continued to travel the world and enjoy married life! Now, they're ready to take the next step and start a family together, making their love story all the more inspiring.
Byron Velvick & Mary Delgado, Season 6 - Broken up
It's been over a decade since Byron Velvick and Mary Delgado split, but their tumultuous relationship is still making headlines. The couple got engaged on Season 6 of The Bachelor in 2004, but their fairytale romance quickly turned into a nightmare. In 2007, Mary was arrested for assaulting Byron following a Bachelor reunion show. The couple tried to brush it off and stay together, but their relationship became increasingly volatile.
They finally called it quits in 2009 after five years together. Despite the drama, Byron has since found happiness with his girlfriend Belinda Solis, while Mary has largely stayed out of the public eye.
Amanda Stanton & Josh Murray , Season 3 - Separated
When Amanda Stanton and Josh Murray met on Bachelor in Paradise Season 3, it seemed like a match made in heaven. They quickly fell in love and got engaged on the show's finale. Josh even moved to California to be closer to Amanda and her daughters. But their fairy tale romance was short-lived. She shared that he was "extremely controlling" during their relationship. Despite her attempts to break up with him, Josh refused to let go.
Their relationship ended in a messy and embarrassing way, with police officers being called to retrieve a car that they shared. It's clear that Amanda and Josh's love story was not meant to last but certainly left a lasting impact on Bachelor Nation.
Lace Morris & Grant Kemp, Season 3 - Broken up
Lace Morris and Grant Kemp's romance on Season 3 of Bachelor in Paradise had viewers on the edge of their seats. From the moment they shared their first kiss, it was clear that they had undeniable chemistry. Despite their ups and downs, the couple seemed to be in it for the long haul when they got matching tattoos and became engaged during the show's finale. But, as it turned out, their love story was doomed.
Just two months after the show aired, Lace and Grant went their separate ways. Apparently, it was a rough breakup with a ton of hostile feelings toward each other.
Britt Nilsson & Brady Toops, Season 11 - Separated
It was the most dramatic season in Bachelor history! The eleventh season of The Bachelorette pitted Kaitlyn Bristowe against Britt Nilsson, allowing the male suitors to choose who they wanted to pursue a relationship with. Tensions were high as the men debated between the two women, and Britt ultimately left the show in tears after she was rejected by the majority of the suitors. But when Brady Toops stepped forward to comfort her, it was a moment that had fans swooning.
He left the show to be with her, but their love story didn't have a happy ending. After a brief romance, Britt and Brady called it quits,
Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray, Season 10 - Broken up
Andi Dorfman and Josh Murray's engagement on The Bachelorette was the stuff of fairytales, but their real-life relationship was far from it. When the cameras stopped rolling, the couple struggled to make things work and ultimately called it quits in 2015. In an interview, Andi revealed that their split was "pretty mutual" and that they realized they just didn't bring out the best in each other. We guess you can't believe everything you see on-screen!
Rumors circulated that their relationship was plagued with jealousy and control issues. Not quite the fairy tale ending we had all hoped for, and a shame it had come to such a bitter end.
Ben Flajnik & Courtney Robertson, Season 16 - Broken up
Ben Flajnik and Courtney Robertson's dramatic relationship was the talk of the town after their tumultuous journey on The Bachelor. We were stunned when the couple called off their engagement, but their on-again, off-again romance kept everyone on the edge of their seats. Even after their split, they continued making headlines with public appearances and dating rumors. Ben was often seen cozying up with Hollywood A-listers while Courtney spilled all the tea in her explosive tell-all book.
Though they didn't find love together, they certainly made the most of their time in the spotlight. Were they really looking for love or just fifteen minutes of fame?
Kaitlyn Bristow & Jason Tartick, Season 11 & 14 - Married
Kaitlyn Bristowe and Jason Tartick's love story is one for the books. Despite not meeting on television, the two Bachelor Nation alums connected through their mutual love for the franchise and quickly hit it off. They first met when Tartick appeared on Bristowe's podcast in 2018, and the chemistry between them was undeniable. After a year of talking and hanging out, they finally confirmed their relationship in early 2019. Since then, they've been inseparable.
The duo, who live together in Nashville with their two golden retrievers, are currently planning their wedding and have been going strong for four years now.
Jason Mesnick & Melissa Rycroft, Season 13 - Broken up
Get ready for some jaw-dropping drama, Bachelor Nation! The seemingly picture-perfect love story between Jason Mesnick and Melissa Rycroft wasn't what it seemed. In the infamous "After the Final Rose" special, Jason blindsided Melissa and the entire audience when he revealed that he had changed his mind and wanted to be with runner-up Molly Malaney instead. Melissa was humiliated and heartbroken, while Molly agreed to take a chance on Jason again.
But was it really worth it? Despite their seemingly happy ending, rumors have been swirling that Jason and Molly's marriage isn't as perfect as they make it out to be.
Matt Grant & Shayne Lamas, Season 12 - Broken up
Bachelor Nation has seen its fair share of dramatic breakups, and the split between Matt Grant and Shayne Lamas was no exception. Matt proposed to Lamas on Season 12 of The Bachelor, but their engagement didn't last long. The couple announced their split shortly after the show finished airing in 2008, stating that they were both heading in different directions. Despite their breakup, Grant and Lamas maintained a close friendship.
Matt later found love and married someone else, while Shayne did the same and had two children before calling it quits in 2021, following 11 years of marriage!